Independent daily Newspaper


 Old Archive RSS Feed    Advertise



 Feature-Europe seems far away in unstable southeast Turkey

 Source : Reuters
  Kurd Net does not take credit for and is not responsible for the content of news information on this page


Feature-Europe seems far away in unstable southeast Turkey 8.12.2005
By Daren Butler


HAKKARI, Kurdistan-Turkey, Dec 8 (Reuters) - In the shadow of mountains bordering Iraq and Iran, Turkey's Hakkari province may one day be an outpost of the European Union. But for now, it feels cut off from the world.

Its picturesque valleys and snowy peaks shelter communities ravaged by more than 20 years of separatist conflict, which has devastated traditional livestock farming and forced many local Kurds to turn to smuggling to earn a living.

Trade opportunities are limited. Hakkari's border to Iraq is closed, trade with Iran is sporadic and there are only limited road links to the rest of Turkey across mountain passes.

"All the doors have been shut in our face and hopes have been dashed. We are effectively being told: 'don't trade officially, smuggle instead'," said Adnan Hatipoglu, general secretary of the local Chamber of Commerce.

"Europe is focused on investing in the west but they should do more for this region. People are suffering here," he said.

In October, Turkey began EU entry talks which are expected to last 10-15 years. Brussels has urged the country to do more to bridge the gap between its prosperous west and the southeast.

With annual per capita income of $800 - around a quarter of western Turkish levels - Hakkari is one of the poorest areas but its problems are felt across the mainly Kurdish southeast.

Successive governments, 1,300 km (800 miles) away in Ankara, have failed to implement bold development plans. Incentive schemes have done little to overcome the concerns of businessmen about investing in a region torn apart by a rebel insurgency.

The outlawed Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) took up arms against the government in 1984, and 30,000 people have been killed in their fight for an ethnic homeland in the region.

Violence tailed off after the capture of PKK leader Abdullah Ocalan in 1999 but last year, the PKK called off a six-year unilateral ceasefire and resumed its attacks on security and civilian targets.

The bloodshed has erased the benefits of a spell of relative peace and underlined the importance of tackling the region's economic plight. Suspected security force involvement in a bomb attack in Hakkari last month has deepened distrust of the state.

"Life in the region has become unbearable. Unemployment has reached 70 percent, livestock farming has been decimated and villages emptied," Hatipoglu said.


One of the few ways to make money is by smuggling fuel. The state turns a blind eye to the semi-illicit trade given the deep poverty in the region.

Some 4,000 trucks ply their trade in the neighbouring Van province near the border, queuing in their hundreds at police checkpoints after bringing in diesel fuel from Iran.

"All the drivers you see here are doing this work because there is no other work," said 39-year-old truck driver Servet, who declined to give his surname.

"Our future depends on the European Union. The trouble is that a lot of drivers have gone into debt to buy the trucks and they are having trouble paying the money back," he said.

Locals want the government to scrap restrictions on when fuel can be transported as well as introduce measures to boost investment in the region. Some would also like authorities to open the border crossing to Iraq to spur trade.

The government has taken some measures to encourage local industry, for example establishing carpet weaving centres but these have met with mitigated success.

In one of the workshops near the Hakkari governor's office, dozens of teenage girls sit at looms, weaving bright patterns into 'kilim' carpets as instructor Fatima Adiyaman looks on.

"This is a way for them to contribute to the household income. It gives them something to do, but there are less women working here than there used to be," she said.

Businessmen say the trade has suffered from inadequate marketing faced with stiff competition from other regions.


For men, livestock was historically the economic mainstay. That too has been dealt a fierce blow with the destruction of some 70 villages in Hakkari in the 1990s as the state looked to choke off support for the PKK rebels in the mountains.

Since then, the number of sheep and goats in Hakkari has fallen to some 500,000 from two million. The number of cattle has declined to some 70,000 from 500,000 over the same period.

Many shepherds and farmers moved into towns, but few found work in the violence-battered economy.

The loss of income was only partially offset by the employment of tens of thousands of Kurds as village guards in a state militia fighting alongside soldiers against the PKK.

Locals now warn the latest violence may undermine widespread Kurdish hopes for the EU process, encouraging youths to join PKK fighters holed up in the nearby mountains of northern Iraq.

In the southeast's main city Diyarbakir, business official Lezgin Yalcin said activity had picked up in the service sector, construction and public investment in recent years but this came to a halt when attacks started again.

Much of the local economy depends on the income of tens of thousands of civil servants and security force personnel, which can give a misleading appearance of relative prosperity in the city's main business district where streets are crowded with branches of the banks and shops found across the west.

"In appearance life has improved, but the new businesses are not making any money. Much of the local economy depends on the civil servants," Yalcin said.

"What the region needs is an end to the violence."



  Kurd Net does not take credit for and is not responsible for the content of news information on this page


Copyright 1998-2016 Kurd Net . All rights reserved
All documents and images on this website are copyrighted and may not be used without the express
permission of the copyright holder.